Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty (2024)

Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty (1)

We’ve all had one of those days when we wake up, look in the mirror and feel our locks need a lift – or even a whole new shade! Applying a box dye can seem like an instant fix, but you’d be hard-pressed to find a hairdresser that agrees. Some boxed hair colours can cause […]

Back to listings

We’ve all had one of those days when we wake up, look in the mirror and feel our locks need a lift – or even a whole new shade! Applying a box dye can seem like an instant fix, but you’d be hard-pressed to find a hairdresser that agrees.

Some boxed hair colours can cause so much damage to your strands that an urge to be spontaneous might become a long-lasting nightmare! That’s why our experts are here to shed light on why the hairdressers you meet will often hate box dye, and how to avoid colour catastrophes in the future.

Once we’ve convinced you not to take the risk – and when you do get the feeling you need a colour boost – find your nearest Rush salon and book an appointment for a luxurious, professional treatment.

In this blog:

What’s the difference between box dyes and salon dyes?

Box dyes are premade, generic formulas for all hair types (which often means they’re particularly concentrated), whereas salon dyes are custom-made to match the individual characteristics of your hair.

Do box dyes damage your hair?

They might do. The main reason some hairdressers hate box dyes is because particular formulas might be too harsh for your hair, but also because the application of hair colour by anyone other than a professional has its own issues.

You might find yourself saying goodbye to shiny, sleek locks and saying hello to a mane with split ends and lifeless texture.

Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty (2) Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty (3)

So what are the risks of using box dye?

1. They’re progressive dyes

Boxed hair colours are usually progressive dyes, which means every application layers over the previous one. This might result in much darker tresses than expected, mismatched roots, and your follicles being exposed to excessive impurities.

Plus, breaking through layers of boxed hair colour isn’t easy and in certain cases, if boxed dye has been used repeatedly on the same hair, it might not be possible to fully lift your ends until the all the colour has grown out.

2. One hair colour can’t suit everyone

As we mentioned earlier, box dyes aren’t mixed to match the unique personality of your tresses; they’re mass-produced to create a colour that anyone can apply, whatever type of hair you have.

So, although you might want an instant transformation from sunny blonde to sultry brunette, a box dye is unlikely to give you the shade you want. Worst case scenario is (depending on your dye history), you’ll end up with dreaded green or orange hues, which are the stuff of nightmares!

3. You could have an allergic reaction

The chemicals and ingredients that make up some box dyes can be harsh on your hair and skin.

Salon products cost more because they are better quality. Hairdressers will also assess your hair type, condition, and colour history to ensure the right type of dye is applied, for the right period of time and to the right areas of your hair.

4. Box dyes don’t give your hair any depth

Another reason hairdressers might hate box dyes is because they usually won’t give your tresses any definition. They eliminate swish-ability by giving your mane one flat shade.

Hair stylists avoid this by consulting with you, to learn what you want from your colour service and then apply the colour artistically, to stop you losing any depth or dimension.

How do you fix box dyed hair?

Hair that has been coloured with a box dye can thankfully be fixed and the most effective treatment is hair colour correction.

By taking into consideration your natural ‘do, colour correction is able to give your hair the TLC it needs, while avoiding further damage.

Keep in mind though that colour correction isn’t always a quick fix to your boxed dye-lemmas. Be patient with a hair stylist you trust, and they’ll be able to work their magic over one long or several salon sessions. This is the healthiest way to get locks you’ll love.

Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty (4) Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty (5)

Now while some hairdressers hate box dyes, our stylists love giving you expert tips, like Sophie Chandler from our fantastic Creative Workshop Team. Sophie shares how you can curl your hair with your straighteners for a true A-list look.

Book nowBack to listings

Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty (2024)

FAQs

Why Do Hairdressers Hate Box Dye? | Rush Hair & Beauty? ›

The main reason some hairdressers hate box dyes is because particular formulas might be too harsh for your hair, but also because the application of hair colour by anyone other than a professional has its own issues.

Why do hairdressers say not to use box dye? ›

Hairdressers formulate custom colours tailored to clients' natural shades, desired looks and hair conditions. Box hues often turn out brassy, muted or uneven. DIY kits also cannot replicate the meticulous sectioning, application and timing of salon services. Mistakes lead to splotchy results.

What do hairstylists hate? ›

Arriving With Dirty Hair

While second-day, or even third-day, hair can be totally acceptable, it's best to arrive without a ton of built-up hairspray. It also goes without saying, but don't head to the salon straight from the gym. Sweaty strands don't make for an overly enthusiastic stylist, and rightfully so!

Is it better to use box dye or go to a salon? ›

If you're looking for long-lasting, high-quality hair color, it's best to leave the coloring to the professionals. At a salon, you can be sure that you're getting a color that is specifically tailored to your individual needs.

Why is professional hair dye better than box dye? ›

It's safer and much gentler on your hair. Professional dye lasts much longer. A professional hair stylist has the knowledge, experience, and training to deliver your desired results.

What do hairdressers use instead of box dye? ›

You might think the hair dyes lining the shelves of your local drugstore are the same as professional in-salon formulas, but the truth is that there are major differences between the two. Box dyes are pre-made formulas that are made for all hair types, while salon hair color is custom made for each client. Box dyes ...

What box dye won't ruin my hair? ›

A top performer in GH Beauty Lab testing, Garnier's permanent color is made with no ammonia and a high concentration of nourishing oil so it's gentle on hair that's damaged from treatments like keratin or thinning strands.

What brand of hair dye do most salons use? ›

What Hair Dye Do Salons Use?
  • L'Oreal Professional Inoa. L'Oreal Professional Inoa is an ammonia-free hair color that is gentle on the hair and scalp. ...
  • Clairol Professional Soy4Plex. ...
  • Wella Koleston Perfect Me+ ...
  • Hair Dye Tips from the Pros.
Nov 4, 2022

Is Sally's hair dye better than box dye? ›

Sally's hair dye is definitely a little better that box dye, but it still isn't up to par with professional grade hair color.

What are the cons of box hair dye? ›

However, there are some downsides to using box dye. Since it's a one-size-fits-all solution, it may not be suitable for all hair types and textures. Additionally, box dye can be more damaging to your hair than salon color, as it often contains harsh chemicals like ammonia and peroxide.

Should I box dye my hair or get it done professionally? ›

1. Box Dyes Can Contain Harsh Ingredients

This process is damaging to your hair and scalp skin and can leave you with an itchy, irritated scalp and dry, brittle hair. Professional hair color formulas are often made without ammonia to reduce scalp irritation and damage to your hair.

Is Wella considered box dye? ›

It's safe to use, washes out in 10 shampoos and is compatible with Wella hair colour that may already exist in the hair. That's why our stylists refer to Wella's Color Fresh as a Semi-Permanent Professional Hair Colour, rather than a box dye – the difference between the two as we have detailed, is vast.

Why is box dye bad for your hair? ›

Box dyes often say they contain moisturising ingredients or are 'ammonia-free'. However, even these usually contain PPDs, salts and other chemicals that will damage hair, especially with repeated use.

Can hairdressers get box dye out? ›

Go to the salon.

A professional colorist should know how to remove hair dye with minimal damage, and they can help correct any color mistakes (like orange hair) that may arise from the removal process. If you're worried about potential damage and hair breakage, ask your colorist to do a test strand.

Can a hairdresser colour over box dye? ›

Yes you can put a professional dye over a box dye but you need to ensure the shades aren't going to clash, the colour can deposit (because you can't lift with colour only deposit) and to get it even you have to apply it in a certain way.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Barbera Armstrong

Last Updated:

Views: 5676

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Barbera Armstrong

Birthday: 1992-09-12

Address: Suite 993 99852 Daugherty Causeway, Ritchiehaven, VT 49630

Phone: +5026838435397

Job: National Engineer

Hobby: Listening to music, Board games, Photography, Ice skating, LARPing, Kite flying, Rugby

Introduction: My name is Barbera Armstrong, I am a lovely, delightful, cooperative, funny, enchanting, vivacious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.